Fifty Labour amendments to kill Bill for EU referendum
More than 50 amendments tabled for committee stage of the EU Referendum Bill, including holding a petition of a million voters, posing the questions in Cornish and giving prisoners the vote
By Matthew Holehouse, Political Correspondent
10:23PM GMT 21 Jan 2014
David Cameron's plan to give the public a vote on membership of the European Union could be defeated within weeks after Labour peers tabled dozens of outlandish amendments that could halt its progress in Parliament.
More than 50 amendments were tabled for the committee stage of the EU Referendum Bill, including holding a petition of a million voters, posing the questions in Cornish and giving prisoners the vote, the Telegraph has learnt.
As a private member’s Bill, it has a limited time to pass through Parliament. It can only be debated on Fridays and must be approved by both houses by February 28.
Conservatives said the amendments amounted to a plot conducted on behalf of Ed Miliband to “talk the Bill to death”.
That would save the Labour leader, who has refused to set out a clear position on the EU referendum, from being portrayed as anti-democratic.
The Bill sets in law a commitment to hold an in/out referendum on Britain’s membership of the EU by 2017. It sailed through the Commons before reaching the Lords.
Fifty-six amendments have been tabled so far, and more are expected before Friday’s committee stage. Forty have been tabled by a single Labour peer – Lord Foulkes of Cumnock, who served as a Scotland minister under Tony Blair.
They include requiring a petition of a million people before the referendum can be held, moving the deadline to May this year, inserting a minimum turnout threshold and giving the Scottish First Minister – Europhile Alex Salmond - a veto.
Lord Foulkes also proposes extending the vote to 16-year-olds, prisoners and EU citizens, and asking the questions in Gaelic, Doric (a Scottish dialect) and Cornish.
Lord Foulkes has tabled amendments to insert the word “consultative” in the Bill and change “must” to “may” – making any referendum optional and non-binding.
“It appears to be a blatant attempt to frustrate the progress of the Bill by unelected peers doing the bidding of their masters,” said James Wharton, the MP who has sponsored the Bill through the House of Commons. “It would be unforgivable if, by playing party political games, they denied the British people their say, especially as it passed without difficulty through the House of Commons.”
Lord Dobbs, the author of House of Cards, who is piloting the Bill in the Lords, said: “This Bill has six clauses but already there are dozens and dozens of amendments. The sheer volume suggests only one thing: that Labour intend to filibuster this Bill. I hope to be proven wrong, but Friday’s committee stage will tell.”
Lord Foulkes told The Telegraph he opposes a referendum and admitted he does not support “most” of the amendments.
But he insisted: “I can guarantee you there will be no filibustering. There are serious matters that need to be considered. It’s a classic operation of backbenchers doing their job of testing a Bill.”
The peer is no stranger to intrigue in the Upper House.
In 2009 he was accused of attempting to “smear” Gen Sir Richard Dannatt, the former Chief of the General Staff who criticised Labour defence strategy, by tabling a series of questions in the Lords about the general’s expenses and personal use of military helicopters. Lord Foulkes insisted the questions were legitimate.
Labour insisted Mr Miliband was not behind the operation.
“George is acting for George. He is not doing anything with permission of Ed or the front bench,” a source said.
The amendments are here:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/eureferendum/10588539/Fifty-Labour-amendments-to-kill-Bill-for-EU-referendum.html