I've followed this case with great interest and, for what it's worth (which isn't much, I do suppose), I disagree with Thokozile Masipa, the judge in the case.
Apparently, she has clearly indicated her own acceptance, that Pistorius did not intend to kill Reeva Steenkamp and could conceivably have mistaken her at the dead of night for an intruder.
She believed that Pistorius was terrified for his life, and thought Steenkamp was safely in bed when he fired four bullets through the wooden door.
When Oscar screamed in court how he had twice shouted, "Get the f*** out of my house!" I guess she was thoroughly convinced by his delivery of what was stunningly shocking theatrical evidence.
Therefore, she concluded, he could
not be guilty of murder.
Professor James Grant, from Wits Law School, said Pistorius could be forced back into the witness box.
"The State is allowed in exceptional circumstances to appeal when the court makes a mistake of law," he said.
He argued that
Judge Masipa asked the wrong question - did he foresee the possibility of killing Steenkamp -
when she should have asked whether he *could* have foreseen the possibility of killing whoever was behind the door.
"So Gerrie Nel - the prosecutor - could put Oscar back on the stand again."
Pierre de Vos, a constitutional law expert, agreed and tweeted: "Surely if you shoot into the door of a small toilet and know somebody is behind the door, you foresee and accept possibility of killing?"
This is my view and it is also the view of Reeva Steenkamp's family and friends.
There is evidence missing and this is currently in the media and is being spoken about by one of Oscar's ex-girl friends, namely Samantha Taylor:
Samantha Taylor said she feared he would kill her and revealed she once hid his gun after he flew into a rage at her
Hmmm? No wonder Reeva locked herself into the toilet. She WAS inside the toilet and she HAD locked herself in. She did not want to come out. It just might have been the case that she did not want to argue with or speak to Oscar at that time too. I wonder why that might have been the case?
I think this is NOT over yet and I do hope we see gun crazy, easily angered Oscar Pistorius back in court after an appeal on the verdict and possibly that verdict then changed to Murder......
....any year soon.