David Cameron is all fine speeches and no action
Does anyone in Downing Street really believe that this strategy will win over the voters, asks Janet Daley.
Master PR man: David Cameron at 10 Downing Street Photo: GETTY IMAGES
Janet Daley
By Janet Daley
7:00PM GMT 29 Nov 2014
Another week, another smart political move from David Cameron. Or was it? The endlessly trailed and ever-so-long-anticipated speech on immigration finally arrived, and in spite of Mr Cameron’s delivery – which implied unambiguous frankness – was immediately subjected to forensic textual analysis. Instead of putting to rest the question of what he really intended to do about the EU, he launched an instant new wave of doubt and interpretation. For all the Kremlinology about how much of this had been pre-agreed with Brussels and sold in advance to the Liberal Democrats, the most concise judg-ment – oddly enough – came from Ed Miliband: people were not going to believe the Prime Minister’s new promises when he had broken the old ones.
Banal it may be as an Opposition leader’s retort, but it does hit what has become the most serious (perhaps fatal) Cameron problem squarely on the head. The example at the top of everybody’s mind was the failure to deliver on the “no ifs, no buts” promise to reduce immigration, which was so inconveniently exposed by the net migration figures the day before the speech.
But only a day before that, there had been another grotesque embarrassment involving another of Mr Cameron’s smart political moves. Remember that brilliant surprise announcement first thing in the morning after the Scottish referendum result? Mr Cameron strode out on to Downing Street and proclaimed that the further devolution he had promised to the Scots would indeed be delivered, but it would have to be accompanied by a parallel undertaking to the English: if Scottish voters were to be given more control over their own affairs, they would have to lose their powers over matters that affected only English voters. Well, as of this moment, that does not appear to be true.
The initial recommendations seem to involve the Scots having their shortbread and eating it. They will not only get more tax-raising powers for themselves, plus the continuation of the Barnett subsidy from Westminster – but their MPs will continue to vote on English budgetary issues. That is what you call hitting the jackpot. Downing Street now says that, in fact, proposals to address the English question will be forthcoming “within weeks”, even though Labour leaders are claiming they have had an assurance that their Scottish MPs will not be shut out of English political matters. So, either Mr Cameron is saying different things to different people or he is about to rewrite the British constitutional settlement on the hoof. I’m not sure which is worse.
Once again, there is either going to be a public sense of betrayal or a fudge designed to give the impression that concrete actions have followed inspirational words. And all of this stems from making smart political moves that consist entirely of saying clever things.
More:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/11261407/David-Cameron-is-all-fine-speeches-and-no-action.html