Behind those allegations the Tories ‘bought the general election’

The Conservatives' 2015 Battle Bus is at the centre of allegations (Photo: Getty)
Nigel Morris 16:43; Friday June 3rd 2016
It started with a £14,000 hotel bill and has escalated into a nationwide police investigation that could theoretically result in several general election results being overturned.
Nigel Farage thought he had lost his best chance of becoming an MP when he failed to capture South Thanet for Ukip at last year’s general election.
But now he faces the possibility – and for now it is no more than that – of a court ordering a rerun of the contest in the Kent constituency where he lost to the Tories by 2,800 votes.
Moreover, other constituencies up and down the country could face the same issue with investigations already underway by 11 police forces.
The Ukip leader told LBC News he hopes and prays “justice is done” and said the country had to “get to grips” with what he views as the major parties bending the spending rules during elections.
The growing focus on the Tories’ spending last year is down to the persistence of Channel 4’s dogged political correspondent, Michael Crick.
He uncovered a £14,000 bill run up by the Tories ahead of polling day at the Royal Harbour Hotel in Ramsgate in the marginal constituency, followed by a receipt for £4,240 from the Premier Inn in Margate.
Strict rules apply
Why the paperwork matters is because of the rules governing the declaration of spending during general election, with a demarcation between expenditure which is judged to be local and national.
Once a campaign is underway, strict limits apply to how much cash a party can throw at an individual contest in an attempt to “buy” victory.
Channel 4 suggested the bills run up in Ramsgate and Margate should have been included in the returns for Thanet South.
It went on to uncover receipts showing more than £38,000 was spent accommodating activists at hotels as they toured the UK in their BattleBus2015 campaign.
The spending was never declared to the Electoral Commission by the Tories, which the party blamed on an “administrative error”.
It played down the significance of the blunder, denying that the receipts would have counted towards local spending limits of around £15,000 per constituency.
Some of the alleged breaches took place in Nigel Farage’s constituency of Thanet South

Nigel Farage speaks to UKIP supporters encouraging them to vote to leave the EU
The BattleBus
Channel 4 claimed that the BattleBus visited 29 seats – and that legal limits would have been breached in 24 of them if the bills had been counted as constituency spending. Twenty-two of the seats on the bus’s itinerary were won by the Conservatives on 7 May.
The claims over South Thanet are now being investigated by Kent police and ten other forces have said they are also examining the party’s spending returns.
They are Cheshire, Gloucestershire, Greater Manchester police, Lincolnshire, Northamptonshire, Nottinghamshire, Staffordshire, Warwickshire, West Mercia (on behalf of Devon and Cornwall), and West Yorkshire.
The Electoral Commission, which is investigating spending in several seats as well as three parliamentary by-elections in 2014, went to High Court to force the Tory party to release relevant documents.
Results could be declared void
This week the victorious Conservative candidate, Craig Mackinlay, mounted an unsuccessful legal attempt to prevent Kent Police having more time to examine his spending returns.
But Timothy Straker, representing the force, told the hearing: “It is exceptional – we have allegations of national funds being used, as it may be put by some, effectively to buy an election.”
District Judge Justin Barron turned down the application and gave detectives another 12 months to investigate.
He ruled that the claims surrounding the Tories’ expenses were on an “unprecedented scale” and could result in “election results being declared void”.
The Tory party, which still insists the spending being investigated amounted to national expenditure, faces a nervous few months.
The chance remains faint of any election results being nullified and by-elections called, but cannot be entirely ruled out until police are no longer pursuing their inquiries.
The constituencies in question
All nine seats visited by the Tory battlebus in the South-West of England were won by the Conservatives as they wiped out Liberal Democrats from their former strongholds in the region.
According to Channel 4 News, legal spending limits could have been breached in eight of them if costs linked to the battle bus had been declared locally. They are North Cornwall, Stroud, Cheltenham, Torbay, Yeovil, Wells, Thornbury and Yate and Camborne & Redruth.
In the Midlands, home to a string of marginal seats, the limit could have been exceeded in seven constituencies. They are Lincoln, Northampton North, Dudley South, Cannock Chase, Broxtowe, Amber Valley and Nuneaton.
Successful contests in nine Northern constituencies visited by the battlebus also potentially breached the spending limit, Channel 4 News reported. They are Rossendale and Darwen, Halifax, Morecambe and Lunesdale, Pudsey, City of Chester, Hazel Grove, Carlisle, Cheadle and Weaver Vale.
In addition, the Electoral Commission is investigating Conservative election spending in three by-elections in 2014 as the party tried to stem a flood of votes to Ukip. They are Clacton and Rochester and Strood – both won by Nigel Farage’s party – and Newark, which was retained by the Tories.