I often find all manner of reference to Technical Analysis whilst reading threads, questioning certain elements, asking for advice on indicators and also requesting advice on a stock and whether it's a good time to buy, sell, hold or remain indifferent. I am the first to admit that my own TA is still in its infancy, but I do spend time on expanding my knowledge (hopefully in the right direction!).

Rather than having to ask a TA question on a particular thread, perhaps this thread could be used as a forum for TA queries and become a knowledge base. Just a thought, if there is little or no interest, the thread will sink without trace and that will be the end of that. I will personally add a few snippets to help those with less knowledge (if that's possible) to keep things rolling. There is a danger that the thread will receive countless requests for opinions on a variety of stocks and there is only so much I can do alone, therefore I would more than welcome input from other posters, no matter how rudimentary they believe their own knowledge to be, hopefully some real experts will take the time to contribute.

Re my post 64 on EMG no need to confirm my thoughts as sp has gone up another 14 at min so must have been a buy signal would appreciate thoughts on sell signal if anyone has the time

OOps sorry thought I'd learned how to paste chart. Back to the drawing board

DOO .... good profit take of mine so far ..... PT - now your chart gets interesting as rsi is sitting smack on 70

SCHE - PT - per current sp, hope you did not short (567 bid) ..... at what juncture does your chart need to "reconsider"?

Richard, no I haven't shorted, was watching L2 earlier and SCHE certainly wasn't showing any signs of wanting to come off. Just gonna look at the chart now and see what's what :)

Rich... lol, this thread is interesting, will you pair take a look at HAWK... are the shorters out in force?, knew i should have waited, fed up with stopping stuff though...

Looks like SCHE has pushed through my shallower channel (pink jobbie) which I thought might provide some resistance and has bounced off the next trendline at around 575 (blue jobbie). So I think a close above 575 ish is certainly time to 'reconsider'. Will have to wait until the close to see where it ends up and I can then take a look at both the MACD and RSI, my feeling is that this is the last oomph before coming off. By rights it should be, the MACD divergence is screaming SELL all on its own :S

Nice to see we got DOO right thus far.

pth

Also noticed that following my words of caution last night WNG is retracing, TAN is struggling with 200p, SOLA has a bit of life, COH is continuing its fall and CSR is still making strides in the right direction. Perhaps I should buy or sell some of this stuff? Seem to be making the right calls generally :))

pth

A word of caution, just because the chart indicates or even confirms a sell or buy signal, do not slavishly enter a trade on that premise alone. I refer to SCHE today which has surprised me a little by scooting through my short level, but I didn't open a trade by sticking to my guns, I watched the SP action and will now wait.

pth

for what it is worth the HAWK chart is below .... however, this is such a new float that it is all bit meaningless ..... i think PT wouldsuggest that there is further to fall on the minimal info we have, but for myself, shall keep holding

Not really a lot to go on in trendline world, I have drawn the main from admission (more or less) so worst case scenario is support at 32p, if it tanks, which I doubt it will. So, trying to judge the rate of fall, I would suggest a 35p support level.

In cases like this where a rapid move in the price action takes place, TA officionados often take one of two approaches or a combination of both. Clearly the SP will retrace at some point, but when it starts where will it stop? There is the popular 50% rule, ie, the SP will retrace 50% of the last move; in this case this is equal to 39p. The other approach is 33% and 67% retracement of the last move, the 67% level is absolutely critical, if it does more than 67% it is more or less assured that a full 100% retracement will take place. Well, the 33% has already gone (44p), so 39p (50%) is the next level to look for and then 67% which spookily enough is at 35p!!

Incidentally you may be aware that these percentage levels are derived from the Fibonacci numbers sequence (made famous by Dan Brown's Da Vinci Code) which forms the basis of Dow Theory and Elliot Wave Theory.

In summary then I don't see any reason to buy at the moment, look for support at 39p and then 35p.

pth

Would somebody please look at emg for me Has passed last high and is still below 70 on RSI so I think it has a bit more to go would appreciate your input

Here you go Maggie, EMG



I don't know if you are trading EMG or simply investing, it may make a difference to your strategy.

Please note that today's price action is not included, but I will update later.

As you can see from the chart EMG is chugging along in a nice bullish channel, the mid line of which I have also drawn. It certainly seems to prefer the lower half of the channel, occasionally popping out to the upper half. Both the MACD and RSI are showing bearish divergence, which would seem to indicate that the latest move is coming to an end. Today's rise certainly means it is nudging the mid channel trendline (resistance) and the RSI must be close to its own resistance line also. I would certainly keep an eye out for any weakness now and perhaps take profits as any retracement could take the SP back to trendline support at 575p. Incidentally the 635p-640p level is also an all time high resistance level, coincidental with the rising trendline resistance, perhaps another reason to take profits at the moment. No-one ever went bust taking a profit :)

pth

Many thanks pth I trade and invest with this share missed last rise trading but am sitting on reasonable profit in shares so will probably set a stop loss. Only started reading this thread and think I'm beginning to understand TA a bit more. Keep up the good work both of you, very interesting.

Time for the evening updates:

COH is now sitting on both uptrend and downtrend support, if it isn't going to 34p needs to make a recovery here. Not much to say it will, although the 50 MA is in the vicinty and that may help, but RSI still falling and MACD signal crossing down.

Anyone short on SOLA needs to exercise some caution now. Todays rise (albeit on slim volumes) has pushed through an important uptrend, just; the RSI has also broken through resistance, just. MACD is turning up, although a little way to go before entering positive territory. Certainly before going long, I would be looking for a signal line crossover on the MACD (red line over the yellow dotted line) and a centreline crossover into positive territory (above zero). As far as being short is concerned I would be looking to see if the uptrend line is going to provide support on Monday, if it does there's no reason not to believe that a return to 560p is on the cards. Sitting on the fence now with this one.

pth

Pleased I didn't short SCHE at 560p! I have drawn a new uptrend line following the confirmed bounce from 530p ish. The rise today has pushed the SP back into the shallower bullish channel, although it did meet resistance from one of my uptrends and subsequently fell back. It looks like both the RSI and MACD still have room for a further rise before meeting resistance, so I'm going to have to eat humble pie and suggest that somewhere in the region of 580p, even 600p may be on the cards. Having said that, I remain convinced this is a shorting opportunity, the bearish divergence on the MACD hasn't changed, problem is finding the right shorting level.

pth

One for Maggie: EMG finished the day having a go at that uptrend resistance. Keep a careful eye on this level, it has three levels of resistance to fight through, all at the same place; trendline res, RSI res and the all time high factor. If it does continue its rise it will be a chart breakout and looking good, any weakness and a fallback as previously mentioned is the likely outcome.

pth

WNG fell back today pretty much as expected. Yesterday's rise posted a BUY indication on the RSI and I have drawn an additional line on this indicator (white horizontal) where should the SP recover to above this level next week a confirmed BUY signal will be given, a classic failure swing. Incidentally anyone buying yesterday as the RSI broke above 30 is probably sitting on a loss at the moment - moral of the story - wait for confirmation, not just an indication.

pth

TAN tried again for 200p but once again fell back. Still hanging onto that steeper channel, but rather tenuous. Still think a smallish correction is due to the region of 180p-185p. RSI is rather inconclusive now, but MACD still capped by a resistance line and continuing to ease off.

pth

i posted the following on the SOLA thread in response to a childish outburst from a certain memeber, but it has some relevance here ......

it is a common misconception, that investors who make use of charts (of which there are many varieties), are stupid enough to think they are the Holy Grail, which of course they are not, though they are very useful tool ....... nevertheless it takes a narrow-minded bigot (none spring immediately to mind!) to refuse to accept that charts and market/share movements are inextricably linked, not least because so many PI investment decisions and computer trading programmes are (effectively) based on or triggered by them ...... thus, whether illogical or not, charts are frequently self-fulfilling.


I'll just expand on charts just a little, though i confess no real knowledge or expertise whatsoever .......

i am a thicko, so i just use the very basic charts that are available on MAM from which i can easily read various daily moving averages and also the rsi ..... on occasion i will also insert a x-hair to highlight a certain price level .... these basic charts will also show up historical price movements and also give a simple straight line indication of where support/resistance could well lie.

PT is a much more sophisticated and intelligent chap, so he can work with and understand a much more sophisticated form of chart which allows the insertion of various lines and angles connecting salient price levels etc ...... for all that it is not entirely surprising that both PT and I often reach the same conclusion, but from slightly different angles, if you will excuse the pun.

finally, my very clever friend who works in the City, uses something called GANN theory, which is a rather more sophiticated version of PT's ...... this works not only on salient price levels, but also incorporates time angles and/or % rises/falls.

However, i would repeat for followers of this thread and even for the odd narrow-minded bigot who may read this, that charts can never be the Holy Grail or we would all have a huge stash of cash and/or private islands and very large yachts ...... a chart is a tool to help investment decisions ..... the amount one relies on them is personal, like any other investment decision.