Forex rebates on every trade - win or lose!

I'm a bit confused by my cable charts atm.

I've drawn a line on the daily charts from the lows of March 2006 passing up through the low of 17th August 2007.

That rising support line on Friday seemed to be around 2.0250 and it appeared to have been broken suggesting bearishness in the months ahead.

That line, however, regenerates itself on all of the other timeframes of my charts and on timeframes of 30-minutes and less it appears to currently be at 2.0110, well over 1 cent lower than on my other charts.

Whereas on Friday I thought that the uptrend support had been broken, I'm not really sure if that's the case this morning. I don't understand how the charts can say two different things.

Hiliconfuscious
FWIW I also had 20250 as a key support and believe it has now been breached. I also have 20110 from another chart using the Dailies. I suppose we are about to see if that one gets breached as well - 'cos it's playing out a test at the moment.

I posted the other day that I thought there was support below 20250 at around 20050 but I now think that 20110 is the correct level to test 'cos I have it as the bottom of the mid-point down channel from early November. The bottom of the full down channel - top 9/11/07 and bottom 16/11/07 I have at around 19800.

All a bit tricky but if it goes then I'll mainly be looking to short down to 19800.

Hilary, I'm not sure I entirely understand your post but are you saying that when you draw the trendline on the daily and then switch to timeframes of the 30m and less the trendline appears to be in the wrong place ?

Daily FX does this all the time. The problem seemed to start about 2 weeks ago but may have been longer. I just became aware I couldn't trust it.

aplogies if i've misunderstood. I moved onto Metatrader since I became aware of the problem. But I think you have Sharescope ?

That's exactly what I'm saying, CC. It's on MetaTrader that it does it. I chopped in my Sharescope a few years ago when they introduced setsmm and I all but stopped trading stocks.

It might have something to do with them taking their daily close at midnight whereas others take their close at 10pm. As a result they have 6 daily candlesticks each week instead of 5.

If I connect the march lows of 2006 to the august 2007 then it goes through 2.0250 as you suggest

If I connect the march lows of 2007 to aug 2007 then I get 2.0125 ish which is what is supplying support at the moment I guess

Incidentally, my hourlies for EUR/JPY suggest that 162.34 might be the low of the downleg since last Wednesday evening.

The 20145 has triggered and I've moved my stop up to entry.

Sorry Seymour been in meetings all morning.

They highlight normally the best trade but comment on all the majors. I'll foward it to your MAM email.

Sent 2 mails to your MAM account.

Thanks Dil, got it & replied, just back from lunch.

I finally close the long from 45 for 70 - not sure if it might turn around here.

Is the carry trade relationship breaking down with the huge amounts of liquidity being pumped into the system?
Are the central banks being conned and instead of borrowing on the carry trade the borrowing is taking place in the home currency?

Attached chart shows gbpjpy to ukx relationship has become odd indeed since late November. gbpjpy has hardly changed depsite a big move both up and down on ftse.




As you can guess I shorted gbpjpy when the ftse index was up at about 240 yet I'm only about 50pips up. Wondering what I should do as if the index starts moving up I could lose the 50pips I do have.

EUR/JPY and GBP/JPY are starting an upleg on the 1-hour chart imo. I wouldn't want to be short (I've been fillinmemanolos long since yesterday), but wdik?

Btw, regarding the correlation between the geppy carry and the FTSE, a peek back at the weeklies to 2000 will show geppy enjoying a straight ride up since October 2000 whereas the FTSE was in decline from then and only started its recovery when Dubbya went into Iraq.

The third side of the triangle is represented by fixed income securities (bonds) which is where the carry trade money was landing between 2000 and 2003. I'd suggest that the strength in equity markets despite the weakness in sterling since the MPC cut in interest rates a few weeks ago has been as a result of money flowing out of the bond markets.

Hilary,
If you want to get rid of the Sunday ticks on Metatrader you need to download metatrader from a broker where they have the clock set to gmt +2 hours as then the Sunday ticks go into the Monday bar.

FXDD offer gmt+3 hours so there are no Sunday bars but i'm not sure what knock-on problems this may cause

I'm ever so pleased you're long EUR JPY Hils, I was yesterday but the curse of the tight stop hit me again - will I never learn!! Anyway, have gone back in again with a wider stop, mainly on the basis of this chart. I also thought when we were up around 165 that it was a short so did .... nothing.

I hate to say this, Seymour, but I offloaded my Yen positions yesterday afternoon based on the dottie line on the M30 hitting 100, as the H1 hadn't really got going by that stage and I figured that a pullback towards the Monday low would quite probably give another entry lower down.

Nice idea, CC. The Sunday bars don't actually bother me as such, but I did wonder if it might be their presence which was causing the cable trendline to perform weirdly.

No worries Hil, I also took my money off last night after posting that, with the same idea of a lower entry.

Well done, Seymour. I'm sure you understand where I'm coming from here, but if the dottie line on H1 had already passed up through 50 by the time that the faster charts (M1, M5, M15) started to pull back then I would probably have left the positions open. As it was, the H1 dottie line had only made it up to about 45 or so and, as such, was susceptible to failure.

I'm still inclined to think that the Monday low (162.35 or something) is likely to hold as support, but I can see it getting back down towards that area today for a retest.

I hope that helps you understand my logic. I'm still targetting that chopper ride for you.

:o)

I wonder if the 6 bars on mt4 on the daily is screwing up some of the readings on some of the indicators like rsi as well as I get different values depending on where i've downloaded mt4 from. I suspect it's affecting the H4 charts as well.