A bit of a long read but it is sunday!!
Posted on Sun, Jun. 26, 2005
Indiana plays catch-up in biofuels race
State sets goals for ethanol and biodiesel
By Jenni Glenn
The Journal Gazette
Dozens of communities in other states are celebrating the construction of ethanol and biodiesel plants the source of millions of dollars in investment, jobs and added value to farmers crops. But Indiana has been slow to join the party, said Andy Miller, state director of agriculture.
The state has just one ethanol plant and no biodiesel plants, despite the fact that Hoosier farmers ranked third in soybean production and fifth in corn production in the nation last year.
The state unveiled a new strategy last month designed to encourage agribusinesses to manufacture ethanol and biodiesel fuel in Indiana, Miller said. The state Department of Agriculture and Indiana Soybean Board have set the goal of turning the state into the Texas of alternative fuels. The states strategic plan for agriculture, released May 17, set a goal of producing 100 million gallons of biodiesel and tripling ethanol production in the state by 2010.
Several proposed plants could help steer Indiana in that direction. Indiana Bio-Energy LLC plans to open a $125 million ethanol plant in Wells County by the end of next year. A subsidiary of the Louis Dreyfus Group has proposed a $100 million agricultural-industrial park in Kosciusko County that could eventually include an ethanol plant and a biodiesel plant larger than any currently operating in the country.
Miller said Indiana has been slow to enter the renewable energy field. The state is the last major corn state to have a major presence in the ethanol industry, he said. The states lone ethanol plant, New Energy Corp., is in South Bend and can produce 102 million gallons of ethanol a year, according to the Renewable Fuels Association, a trade association for ethanol producers.
I wont say were late to the game in ethanol, but were pretty close to being late, Miller said. This markets still got a lot of upside potential for growth.
The fuel, made from processed corn, is either mixed with gasoline or used alone to power cars. The nation produced 3.41 billion gallons of ethanol last year, a 21 percent increase from 2003, according to the Renewable Fuels Association.
Biodiesel use also is growing quickly, said Jenna Higgins, spokeswoman for the National Biodiesel Board in Jefferson City, Mo. Biodiesel is made from soybean oil and then blended with diesel fuel to power trucks. An estimated 25 million gallons of the fuel was blended for use last year. Higgins said that was a large increase from the 500,000 gallons used in 1999.
Demand for biodiesel is expected to rise from 30 million gallons in fiscal year 2004 to at least 124 million gallons a year, thanks to a tax incentive that makes biodiesel price- competitive with diesel fuel, according to the Indiana Soybean Board.
Most of the plants producing the renewable fuels are in Iowa, Minnesota, South Dakota and other states in the western Corn Belt, said Wells County farmer Randy Plummer, an investor and member of the board of directors for the Wells County ethanol plant. The first plants headed to the western Corn Belt states, in part, because their corn prices tend to be lower than those in Indiana, said Plummer, who is also a Wells County commissioner. The states also offered incentives such as tax breaks to encourage plant construction, he said.
Progress has been slower in Indiana, Plummer said.
Were, Id say, coming out of the gate, and the rest of the horses are about halfway around the track, he said.
Iowa, the national leader in ethanol and biodiesel production, has 16 ethanol plants and three biodiesel plants, said Lucy Norton, executive director of the Iowa Renewable Fuels Association. Seven more ethanol plants and another biodiesel plant are under construction in the state.
To draw those plants to Iowa, state groups organized monthly meetings where experts spoke to potential plant owners about the financing, technology and other aspects of constructing a plant, Norton said. The Iowa Department of Agriculture, the Iowa Corn Growers Association, the Iowa Farm Bureau and the Iowa Department of Economic Development set up the meetings held from 1999 to 2001. Norton said the meetings made the difference in persuading people to invest in plants in Iowa.
It takes a partnership with the state and the industry, she said.
A supply of inexpensive corn is important for making an ethanol plant profitable, said Monte Shaw, spokesman for the Washington, D.C.-based Renewable Fuels Association. Iowa ranked first in corn production and second in soybean production last year, according to Indiana Agricultural Statistics, the state division of the National Agricultural Statistics Service.
Indiana has the ingredients for a successful renewable fuels industry, Director of Agriculture Miller said. The state has the grain needed to support plants, as well as the railroads needed to transport renewable fuels to market.
Indiana is closer to the crucial East Coast market than other Midwestern states, Plummer said. Ethanol is used widely in New York and Connecticut to replace an octane additive in gasoline banned by the states. The states proximity to this market helped make the Wells County plant a viable investment, he said.
The state is staying involved in the development of new forms of bio- energy and improvements on existing technology, Miller said. Purdue Universitys research on bioenergy will help the state stay on the front end of new advances in the field, he said.
Despite being a little late on some of the initiatives, we can still be a leader going forward, he said.
Miller declined to provide an exact number of proposed plants in the state, but he said he hears almost daily from new groups interested in building plants
Not all of the proposals will come to fruition, Plummer said, although he is confident his group will be able to raise $25 million in grants or in the form of second-lien loans, which can be paid off after the buildings mortgage, to pay for the Wells County plants construction. Indiana Bio-Energy LLC conducted a feasibility study to make sure the plant would be profitable and increased the proposed size to ensure it would be, Plummer said. Some of the proposals may not make it past the feasibility study because they would not make money, he said.
The amount of capital needed to enter the industry is growing, Miller said. Large corporations, such as the Louis Dreyfus Group that may build in Kosciusko County, are entering the industry in increasing numbers while the number of investor-funded plants is falling, he said.
Indiana is working to increase the use of renewable fuels as well as production. About 3 percent of the gasoline used in the state has some ethanol blended in it, Miller said. The Department of Agricultures goal is to increase that to 10 percent by 2010.
An increase in usage would raise the price farmers receive for their grain. When consumers demand 100 million gallons of biodiesel fuel, soybean prices rise about 10 cents a bushel, according to the Indiana Soybean Board.
The state already has a convenient way of supplying biodiesel to dealers, the National Biodiesel Boards Higgins said. Countrymark Cooperative LLP, based in Indianapolis, has four biodiesel terminals where the soybean-based fuel can be mixed with diesel directly from a pipeline as it is poured into a truck for transport. There are only 12 such terminals in the country, but dealers prefer to use them instead of mixing their own fuel, Higgins said.
We would consider Indiana a leader in biodiesel because of their strong distribution network and high-profile users, Higgins said. The city of Fort Wayne uses a blend of biodiesel fuel in its diesel trucks.
Most of the biodiesel used in Indiana is manufactured in Ohio or west of Chicago. But there is still room in the growing renewable fuels market for Indiana to become an industry leader, said Michael Ladisch, professor of agricultural and biological engineering at Purdue University in West Lafayette. Ethanol use alone has the potential to increase by 50 percent in the future, he said.
The best time to get in the business is when ethanol is expanding, he said. In other words, the market is increasing, so this is the time to get market share.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ethanol production
Indiana lags behind several of its Midwestern neighbors when it comes to ethanol production. Indiana ranked eighth among the states in terms of ethanol production capacity, calculated in million of gallons produced a year, as of January.
Iowa1,262.5
Illinois816
Minnesota523.6
Nebraska523
South Dakota456
Wisconsin210
Kansas149.5
Indiana102
Missouri100
Tennessee67
Michigan50
North Dakota33.5
New Mexico30
Texas30
Kentucky25.4
California8
Wyoming5
Ohio4
Colorado1.5
Washington0.7
Total4397.7
Source: Renewable Fuels Association
http://www.fortwayne.com/mld/journalgazette/11990974.htm
wilbs