The sting....
Cameron answers 'English question' and conjures nightmare for Miliband
English votes for English laws pledge could tighten the Tories grip on power and reduce Scotland's voice at Westminster
Patrick Wintour
theguardian.com, Friday 19 September 2014 11.09 BST
The English question, long buried, has rushed to the centre of British politics as David Cameron announced that devolution of further powers to Scotland will be dependent on a broader agreement that, in future, English MPs alone will vote on English issues.
The prime minister, of course, did not make this clear when he made his vow to the Scottish people in the Daily Record along with Nick Clegg and Ed Miliband. He kept silent because he knows the issue is so entangled that it would have diluted his devolution pledge, given at a time when polls were suggesting Scotland might vote yes.
The implications of Scottish MPs being excluded from the Commons on an array of issues is not just a constitutional thicket, but also a crude political nightmare for Miliband, the Labour leader, since he is likely to have rely on a phalanx of Scottish MPs to secure an overall majority for much legislation.
On the face of it, Cameron, in his dawn statement on the steps of Downing Street, said that if issues such as tax and welfare were devolved to Scotland, then Scots MPs would have to be excluded from votes on these issues. If carried through, the pledge raises the question of whether a Scotland-based constituency MP could again be chancellor of the exchequer or vote on the budget. Indeed, one English Conservative MP, Bernard Jenkin, has said a Scottish chancellor must be a thing of the past.
Labour will react warily to the idea, knowing it may seem popular in England and is already being demanded by the UK Independence party (Ukip). But initial reaction from senior Labour figures such as Owen Smith, the shadow Welsh secretary, was hostile. "The last thing Scotland needs is a constitutional fix which reduces Scotland's voice at Westminster & strengthens Tories' grip on power," he tweeted. "Farage and Cameron united today in responding to yesterday's decision by seeking to concentrate more power in their hands & at Westminster," he added.
More:
http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/sep/19/david-cameron-english-question-ed-miliband-scotland