An excelent item from the OFEX stalwart himself thirdeye. I just happen to think this is probably the best write up/summary of any company I have seen.................
Ok, bear with me before you shoot or stick the knives in & at least listen to the reasoning & please give sensible constructive negative or even positive.
First of all, I got shot down in flames for mentioning this share at 10p on here, but I feel I have earned another write up as it has progressed circa 270% & now stands at 37p, and indeed has been stagnant for almost a year, which is why I think it is in the value zone again.
Ok it was on Ofex with one market maker, but now it has four market makers & indeed more than one institution has invested in the share & furthermore is very likely to move to AIM maybe within 1 year at most.(I think much less)
The share is in the financial sector & lends out money to people who simply cannot otherwise get credit to buy motor vehicles. Now because they charge a decent rate for this, some argue they overcharge, but my take is if you are taking a damn site more extra risk, should you charge a low risk rate of say 9.9%? My answer is absolutely not, you charge what the market can charge, within reason, and nothing that is obviously a rip off such as say an average of 50%+pa. Personally I see an average lending rate of about 30% as the outer limit for much higher than normal risks, and this company just about hits that charging an average of 31%. Indeed the market is competitive, so they aren't going to be able to charge what they want.
Their record is impressive:
The record so far:
Turnover
2000 687,000
2001 1,248,304
2002 1,664,531
2003 2,466,679
2004 3,692,683
Pre-tax profit
2000 67,631
2001 107,502
2002 179,063
2003 308,979
2004 746,792
Portfolio
2000 182,000
2001 709,000
2002 2,200,000
2003 5,300,000
2004 11,100,000
Earnings per share*
2000 0.3p
2001 0.5p
2002 0.8p
2003 1.5p
2004 2.8p
Years 2000-3 estimated eps using relevant tax charge & number of shares in issue at float.
Now as well as lending out the cash they insure circa 70% of their business thus insuring their bad debt risk is heavily reduced & indeed they make money on the insurance policies as well. Furthermore vehicles can be recovered for any other debtors who shoud default.
Ok lending to the highest risk clients, you surely have to have a high bad debt rate, YES car credit just announced circa 17% bad debts and indeed made impressive profits, so surely lending at this end of the market to even higher risk clients this company should be what at about 20% bad debts?
Erm actually no, they (as far as I know) have the best bad debt record in the industry by a long way, Yes car Credit 17% as I have mentioned & Cattles I think have somewhere near 8%, so what does this company have? Well at the results announced last month their bad debt rate was 1.5%.
The MD tells us in July the prospects are excellent. They have indeed just invested in a new web based computer system I quote from the Annual report:
WEB-BASED COMPUTER SYSTEM
The Group has invested in a web-based state of the art computer system. We
believe that the motor finance market place is an inefficient market. The
company intends to exploit the inefficiencies within the market by providing an
unrivalled car funding solution. The new system allows the introducer to input
the credit application details via the Internet, and check the progress of the
application. The system links automatically to Experian and Car Data check and
returns the consumer search, vehicle details and vehicle valuation. The result
will be vastly improved proposal response times and increased capacity in both
the Instalment Credit and Brokerage Divisions. The speed of decision making on
proposals is of key importance to both our existing introducers, and to
potential new introducers. Our belief is that by providing a faster, more
efficient service the potential for growth in this market place is vast.
Furthermore, the company's costs are largely fixed & now the portfolio has reached 12m, turnover will largely feed through to the bottom line as this company has much spare capacity & unlike for example YES car credit doesn't have many branches to operate or indeed need capital expenditure to expand the network, but operates from one central office with plenty of spare capacity.
It also has a brokerage division for the clients it doesn't wish to lend money to, becoming a "one stop shop" the beauty of this is, this company now writes the "cream" business in house & brokerages out the business it doesn't want for a decent fee to other motor finance companies. Maybe the bad debt ratio, becomes more understandable now.
The compound profit growth is 85% over the last four years & 75% for earnings per share growth. Of course with costs now covered some are expecting good growth this year in excess of last. What if they could hit as still a small company only capitalised at 7.5m decent compound growth the next 5 years, is it really impossible?
Who knows, but just out of intrest I worked out the figures, I remember Bodyshop on the USM & Fisher Karpark Electrics performing superbly for me & fantastic compound growth, however I think this company is better & the growth more sustainable. Some may think it's a fantasy model, but lets see what happens if we give the eps & shareprice in kilter growth of 90% (2.5% better than last year) this year reducing 10% each year down to 50% in year five.
Well this is what happens and with the share price being circa 37p for almost a year now, it hardly has an inflated platform share price to start it off.
37p year 1 becomes 70.3p & 5.32p eps (90% growth)
70.3p year 2 becomes 126.5p & 9.57p eps (80% growth)
126.5p year 3 becomes 215p & 16.27p eps (70% growth)
215p year 4 becomes 344p & 26.03p eps (60% growth)
344p year 5 becomes 516p & 39.04p eps (50% growth - p/e 13)
Not easy of course, but I think possible, it will only be acheiving in fact less than it has just acheived overall.
This share does have some warrants & options at 10p, so to accomodate these the figures in year 5 become:
30.69p fully diluted & pro-rata share price 399p.
Ok many won't agree but at least it demonstrates growth & at least I am not using figures (other than the 2.5% increase in growth this year) that the company hasn't acheived before. Also I accept growth gets harder as years go by, but this company is still young & indeed enters a phase where at least short term growth should actually improve on past years as central costs are covered & turnover feeds through to profits as previously mentioned. Futhermore I accept it has hoops to jump through & it's much easier to write down impressive figures than acheive them, but it does give a flavour of what is possible & indeed even the most conservative folk I would hope agree their is plenty of scope for the shareprice even if it hits growth much more modestly.
The share has 4 market makers, it's market cap is 7.5m it has 20,395,250 shares in issue. Directors hold 53.5% & indeed some shares were sold to pay off the MD's mortgage many months ago. Ruegg the corporate advisor has assured Unquoted Analyst these sales are now finished & indeed the company has delivered first class results since the sales.
Finally money has been raised at the following prices by institutions & it is thought that no more money may be required to fund the growth, although we now await the new lending facility to be announced with Barclay's.
Float Money raised @ 10p
Further funds @ 15p
Further funds @ 24p
Further funds @ 26p
Further funds @ 36p
If you are still interested after all that here is a link to the name of the company & the most recent results & Chairman's statement:
http://www.ofex.com/cgi-bin/news.cgi?action=CoStory&ISIN=GB0031884421&NewsID=19826
cheers GF.